I have noticed a lot more teachers talking about how kids use technology in a negative way, and saw an opinion piece in the NY Times this a.m. that says, it's not just kids. Here's an interesting excerpt that mentions some books on the subject that might pique educators' interests:
"Evgeny Morozov, author of “The Net Delusion: The Dark Side of Internet Freedom,” said Twitter creates a false intimacy and can “bring out the worst in people. You’re straining after eyeballs, not big thoughts. So you go for the shallow, funny, contrarian or cynical.”
Nicholas Carr, author of “The Shallows: What the Internet is Doing to Our Brains,” says technology amplifies everything, good instincts and base. While technology is amoral, he said, our brains may be rewired in disturbing ways.
“Researchers say that we need to be quiet and attentive if we want to tap into our deeper emotions,” he said. “If we’re constantly interrupted and distracted, we kind of short-circuit our empathy. If you dampen empathy and you encourage the immediate expression of whatever is in your mind, you get a lot of nastiness that wouldn’t have occurred before.”
Leon Wieseltier, literary editor of The New Republic, recalled that when he started his online book review he forbade comments, wary of high-tech sociopaths.
“I’m not interested in having the sewer appear on my site,” he said. “Why would I engage with people digitally whom I would never engage with actually? Why does the technology exonerate the kind of foul expression that you would not tolerate anywhere else?”
Why indeed?

Your inclusion from Nicholas Carr about how technology is eroding our ability to "think before we speak" really struck a cord with me. I need more than the ten fingers on my two hands to count the number of times the assistant principal and I have dealt with "nastiness" online via Facebook and/or Skype between students. In almost all cases the student admitted that they wished they had not made the comment only minutes after sending it. It would appear that, in the infamous race between the Tortoise and the Hare, the brain is the Tortoise and the mouth, not to mention the keyboard, is the Hare.
ReplyDeleteDefinitely some food for thought. Thanks for sharing Denise.
Your Tortoise and the Hare analogy hits the nail on the head in a way that resonates perfectly with a children's librarian and, I imagine, students in general. Well said Nick.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed this discussion and loved the analogies.
ReplyDelete